PC 040705 - Laserfiche WebLink

Mary Roberts, PO Box ]. 54, noted that she was not related to Allen Roberts and had no obj action to this project. She noted that the caretaker's unit was being relocated and that the Berlogars' house was constructed. before the design guidelines for the Specific Plan_ She noted that there were no deed restri coons that the second unit must remain as such; she did not want future owners to split the propcrty. She would like to sea low-level lighting without up-lighting, such as was discussed for the Happy Valley area. She noted that people had a tendency to install huge lights in front of the barn door, creating light leakage. She did not believe that fill could be exported until there was a final neap for the other propcrty_ Ms_ Nerland believed that the till would remain on that parcel- Mr_ Shutts noted that the lighting could be controlled, using only general illumination required by Code; he did not object to a condition detailing that requirement. Regarding the grading, he noted that the only area of fill would be in the area of the wine barn, which required some excavation of the hillside. He noted that would create a balance in the ti l7_ THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. In response to an inquiry by Chairperson Maas regarding second units, Ms_ Decker stated that the caretaker's unit was not considered as a second residential unit for the site because it relocates the existing caretaker's unit from the existing location and was previously approved at the time the Vineyard C=orridor Specific Plan was adopted. It is not in conformity with the second residential unit requirements with respect to size_ Deed restrictions would not be required because the structure was specific to the caretaking of the site and. its accessory structures_ Commissioner Arkin moved to approve Case PDR-336 as recommended by staff, with the added conditions that only low-level exterior lighting be used and that the underground wine cellar meet all health and safety requirements_ Commissioner Maas seconded the motiou_ Commissioner Blank proposed an amendment requiring the addition of a fourth tree on the hay barn, a sixth tree on the shop and wine barn, and the addition of some natural lau dsca piu~ around the future horse bar~~ Commissioners Arkin and Maas agreed to amend the motion as proposed. KOLL CALL VOTE: AYES: Commissioners Arkin, Blank, and Maas. NOES: Nonc_ ABSTAIN: None_ RECUSED: Commissioner Roberts_ ABSENT: Commissioner Fox_ PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES April 7, 2005 Page 10 of 15