CCMIN101894 - Laserfiche WebLink

Peter MacDonald, 400 Main Street. representative of Mrs. Lew, suggested that Council develop and adopt genetic rules to apply to any piano teacher in any neighborhood without notice to all the neighbors. He believed Council could make a finding that one teacher teaching one student at a time in a home is not a nuisance and does not create a traffic haT~rd. He believed the public heating process stirred up past hatreds and created bitterness in the neighborhoods, Mr. MacDonald did not believe the hours of teaching should be set by the neighborhood. He objected to allegations of Mrs. Lew's violations of the previous home occupation permit and related a history of operations at the premises. He stated the staff report raised three issues: noise, traffic and crime. Mr. MacDonald indicated the piano playing could not be detected beyond the property limits. With regard to traffic, he stated that 50% of the students walk or tide their bicycles to the lessons. At the worst case, if each student were dropped off by a parent and then picked up after the lesson, the most traffic would be four trips per hour, which is not too much for a residential area. He referred to an allegation of concerns about strangers casing the neighborhood for Cambodian gangs. He presented suggested modifications to the conditions of the use permit. He indicated Mrs. Lew needed additional hours to allow flexibility for students to make up missed lessons. He stated piano teachers try to have 40 students per week in order to break even financially. He objected to making parents park in the driveway and forcing Mrs. Lew to clean her garage. Gall Lew, 2145 Camino Brazos. desctibed her professional associations and a history of her teaching since the 1970's. At the beginning, no restrictions or permits were required. However, that situation has changed. The conditions are her major concern. She did not believe there was a traffic problem and she stressed that the request for more hours is to accommodate the schedules of her existing students, not to add more. She stated she had lost four students to another teacher who does not have the same conditions imposed on her. She believed there should be one set of rules applicable to all teachers in the city and disgruntled neighbors should not establish city policy. She believed the four neighbors currently objecting to this permit were acting on the basis of past problems. In reference to the concern about bring strangers into the neighborhood, Ms. Lew reviewed the ethnic makeup of her students and felt that her piano teaching is not the real issue in this neighborhood. She reviewed the actual car trips to her home in a week which averaged three cars per day. She believed the fact that her two teenage sons had gone away to college had drastically reduced the traffic in the neighborhood. She objected to the requirement of parking in her driveway and stated that a parent parked in front of her house is not a traffic hazard. She pointed out that Camino Brazos is a public street and the parents of her students pay taxes in Pleasanton and should be allowed to use it. She referred to a map of the neighborhood and read the addresses of students who walk to their lessons. Ms. Lew presented a petition signed by her supporters. 10/18/94 - 6 -