PC 02/14/96 - Laserfiche WebLink

. . . Commissioner Hovingh commented that he would pursue a reduction in the size of the monument signs to match the dimensions in the previous application. He would also like to remove the south wall sign. Mr. Dai responded that the proposed signage size is within the Hacienua Sign Guidelines; given the area of the land, he does not feel the sign is too large. PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED Commissioner Hovingh spoke about his concern for air quality and car emissions with regard to drive-through windows. He inquired if there should be a condition stating that the drive-through window be closed at times of poor air quality. Commissioner McGuirk basically agreed with Commissioner Hovingh, but disagreed that such a condition should be added to this particular application. Commissioner McGuirk feels this would be better addressed in an ordinance. Staff added that the studies regarding dtive-through windows and air quality have no clear-cut conclusions; the latest study completed for the General Plan indicates that drive-throughs may actually cause less air pollution than stopping and restarting cars for walk-in customers. Discussion ensued regarding Commissioner Wright's personal dislike for drive-through windows and inquired if he should abstain or vote no on the application. Mr. Beougher advised that he does not have to give any reasons for a "no" vote. Commissioner Wright stated he would not be supporting the application, based Oil his personal dislike for drive-throughs and because of Arby's lack of success in Dublin. Chairman Lutz commented that it is not clear to him that drive-through windows are any worse than cold starts of engines at regular walk-in restaurants. He also feels the City Council has stated the Commission should consider applications based on the General Plan as it exists now, not the draft update. Commissioner McGuirk motioned, seconded by Commissioner Barker, making the use permit findings and recommending approval of Case PUD-81-30-61D and UP-96-02 subject to the conditions listed in Exhibit B, with the following modifications: Condition 16: Condition 70: as stated by staff. Staff to review the Chabot driveway to enhance the safety features and bulb out as determined by staff. ROLL CALL VOTE AYES: Commissioners Barker, McGuirk, and Chairman Lutz NOES: Commissioners Hovingh and Wright ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None Commissioner Hovingh stated he could not make Finding B for public health and safety, Resolution No. PC-96-09 was entered approving Case PUD-81-30-61D and UP-96-02, as motioned. Planning Commission Minutes Page 5 February 14, 1996