PC 102214 - Laserfiche WebLink

Mr. Dolan stated that this is something that they can definitely take a look at. He noted that there are some things to balance, and people have taken their shots at Pleasanton Gateway tonight. He pointed out that one of the reasons for Pleasanton Gateway's parking problem has to do with the design and all the vibrant establishments there at the smaller parking lot. He explained that the real problems happen when the restaurants are full, and when this vibrancy creates a parking problem, then it becomes necessary to have some spaces that are not quite as demanding mixed in and consider some limitations on the percentage that could be allotted to certain uses there. Commissioner Allen commented that it would be good to know that certain types of businesses would be no more than, say, 10 percent; to the degree that it could potentially be 30 percent creates a feel that it is out of balance and relates to the health of the center. Mr. Dolan agreed. Chair O'Connor stated that he understands the reasoning behind a discussion in the staff report regarding limiting the percentage of restaurants because of the problem at Pleasanton Gateway, but he is not certain he would want to tell the project owners how to run their business. He pointed out that no one wants to run out of parking or get it so congested that people will stop coming, because then the tenants will leave. He noted that he thinks it is best to let the owners decide how they are going to do their mix; beyond that, staff would have to determine what is allowed and what is not: for example, pre -owned clothing or a second -hand store are either allowed or conditionally allowed in some parts of Pleasanton, but he would not want to see a Goodwill store on the first floor. Chair O'Connor stated that he does not like the look of having signage on the upper floor at the top of the gutter line. He noted that the way some of these signs are all over the place looks so busy, particularly where there is signage in the middle and then signage at the top. He suggested that a better way might be to tuck the signage underneath the overhang for the walkway. He added that he would not want to put a gas station in here; other than that, the other mixes are fine. Commissioner Ritter agreed with Chair O'Connor that the Commission is responsible for zoning but not for picking the type of businesses, and with Mr. Dolan that the Commission can determine the percentages and /or types of permits allowed to manage parking issues. He pointed out that this location is right next to a park and he could envision people parking here, go get a sandwich, and eat at the park. He suggested that putting a parking lot near this side of the park so people could park there instead of at this parking lot. He agreed that self - service gas stations would make traffic even worse. Commissioner Balch inquired if Item 19 under Permitted Use /Office, Emergency standby electricity generator, fuel cell, and battery facilities, is a common allowed use or if it should be a conditionally allowed use. Mr. Dolan replied that it is a common allowed use in the zones off of which this list is based. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, October 22, 2014 Page 27 of 30