PC 112812 - Laserfiche WebLink

• Heritage Trees — The native trees in the setback area along the creek will be preserved, but not the others. • Cul -de -Sac — He is willing to look at various configurations, and he is open to having a common public space versus private space. Christine Bourg, PHA Boardmember and resident and owner of a Downtown Historic home, stated that she has attended all the Historic Task Force meetings, although she is not a member of that Task Force. She indicated that she concurs with the comments made by Commissioner Pearce about considering the demolition of the 100 -year home while the Task Force is still meeting. She agreed that Ponderosa Homes has done its work based on what the Downtown Specific Plan and the Downtown Design Guidelines currently say, and to establish the house in order to save the house sometimes requires proof that it would be a historic resource according to the California Historic Register. She noted that these are not being considered now in the Task Force; however, the documents indicate that an early occupant of the home, the Hall Family, has significant history here in Pleasanton. She recalled that during discussions on a Neal Street application to build a home, the Hall Family home at 215 Neal Street came up and the family was considered to be significant locally as they were involved in bringing the County Fair to Pleasanton. She added that Mr. Hall had significant holdings Downtown in warehouses and granaries, and the Hall Family also purchased this land and built the house that Ponderosa is proposing to demolish. Ms. Bourg noted that the staff report states that the house shows some disrepair, but it could possibly be restored and /or relocated. She stated that rather than looking at this as an opportunity to demolish a house and develop 14 new homes, it should be considered as an opportunity to save the old home in front and restore it so that there will actually be a heritage home on that south side of Stanley Boulevard, the side that has most of the old homes left. She continued that it could be a win /win situation with a great frontage to whatever homes are put behind it, and it could also be used as a great marketing tool as people come to Pleasanton because they like the old homes and the old feel. Ms. Bourg stated that if the City required restoration /relocation in more cases, the City would have kept more of the homes we had /have, which are diminishing in number. She noted that there was one building demolished on Third Street within the last six months and building is starting on that; and the one directly across the street from the subject property is the 1908 bungalow which was approved for demolition within the last year, and which the developer of the property would now like to relocate that home. She added that it would be a great idea to relocate it across the street so there could be two actual heritage homes which fit in with the character of the Downtown. Ms. Bourg agreed with Commissioner O'Connor that the homes be designed to look a little bit more like craftsman, and it would really be great if they took on some of the characteristics of the 100 - year -old Victorian home in front. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, November 28, 2012 Page 12 of 38