PC 10/27/99 - Laserfiche WebLink

Jack Keane, 417 Sycamore, noted the approval for landscaping was granted in 1997 and that the house is approximately 3500 square feet, contrary to what was contained in the staff report. He commented on the animosity that has developed on the part of Mr. Dingman toward the Keane family. He commented on the compromises that he has made including relocating and reducing the size of a bedroom window, and relocating and amending the size and types of trees. He noted that he has worked with the neighbors to develop a feasible plan. In conclusion, he noted his willingness to compromise and accept the Planning Director's recommendation, and he requested that the appeal be denied. He submitted a memorandum to the Commission from John Severini. Discussion ensued relating to Condition No. 7. Earl Bach, 446 Sycamore Road, commented on the recent City Council meeting that Mr. Dingman attended. He noted that the City staff has created a situation which could turn dangerous, in his opinion. He commented on the behavior of the Dingmans. He commented on the beauty of the Keanes' landscaping and noted that the landscaping is adequate at the present time; however, he stated that the Keanes are willing to meet staff's recommendations. Hoss Bozorgzad, 6546 Arlington Court, noted that the Keane's are reasonable and compromising people who seek to keep the neighborhood and community as pleasant as possible. He requested that the Commission support staff's recommendation. PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED Commissioner Kameny noted it is unfortunate that the process has evolved to this point and he noted that staff has made a recommendation to alleviate the problem by modifying the landscaping plan. He commented on how unfortunate it is when there is discord among neighbors. He stated that if staff feels that the modified plan will accomplish what the original plan should have done, he would be in support of approving the modified plan and with denying the appeal for this application. Chairperson Roberts commented on the recent City Council meeting that Mr. Dingman attended and she noted she would be in favor of approving the modified plan. Commissioner Maas stated that if the applicant agrees with the modified plan, the plan should be approved. Commissioner Kumaran empathized with the applicant and he noted that staff has attempted to resolve all issues in the modified plan. Commissioner Sullivan made a motion to uphold staff's approval of the Modified Plan by denying the appeal. Commissioner Kameny seconded the motion. A motion was made by Commissioner Sullivan, seconded by Commissioner Kameny, to uphold staff's approval of the Modified Plan by denying the appeal. ROLLCALLVOTE PLANN1NG COMMISSION MINUTES 15 October 27, 1999