PC 11/29/1995 - Laserfiche WebLink

Commissioner McGuirk clarified with the speaker that he would like to remove the second- story elements of the buildings backing up to his property as well as increasing the rear yard setbacks. In Mr. Glanville's opinion, this would make it similar to having single family homes behind his property. Commissioner Barker asked Mr. Glanville if breaking the building into three separate buildings would be acceptable. Mr. Glanville stated he would have to see the plans. He feels the simplest solution would be to delete the second story element. Mr. Glanville stated he was very disappointed in staff and the developer for not talking with him about the project. He learned of the project within one week of it going before the City Council. Mr. Hovingh inquired of staff, and staff concurred, that if this project were a single family project, the height of the houses could be four feet higher than the height of the current proposed project. Robert Bielby, 265 Del Valle Ct., is very upset with the project. He is not against senior citizen housing, but he does not want to view a row of apartments across the street. He feels this project is out of place for their neighborhood. The fact that it is a senior citizen apartment complex does not make it any less visible and more palatable to the speaker. He also believes the neighbors' concerns have not been accurately reflected in the staff reports. The neighbors continuously focused on the fact that the second-story units would be viewing into their backyards. Mr. Bielby also feels the staff reports are biased toward this project and developer; furthermore, he does not believe the developer is necessarily looking to fill a need in Pleasanton, he is looking at profits, knowing the City gives concessions for senior affordable housing. Mr. Bielby does not approve of a density of 97 units in this area. He also does not believe the stated rental is lower than what one can rent a studio apartment for in Pleasanton. He feels his property value is paying for this developer's profits. Mr. Bielby suggested a win- win situation by removing the second story, the courtyard would become wider, the natural lighting would not be affected, and the adjoining property owners would be satisfied. Mr. Bielby also expressed his concern that this project is moving too fast and asked that more time be taken to consider the project before a decision is made. Rich St. John, 4275 Rosewood Drive, the managing agent for Del Valle Manor, stated they attended the first neighborhood meeting and do not believe they have been given any concessions they didn't have coming to them. The setbacks on the west side are remaining at 10-15 feet. They are concerned with the density, parking, carports, but feels the overall type of project is good. Mr. St. John concluded Del Valle Manor is in favor of the project but would like the same considerations as those given to the Glanville/Finn properties. Planning Commission Minutes Page 11 November 29, 1995