_Minutes_January 12, 2022 - Laserfiche WebLink

properties. She stated gallon sized plantings were common but box size trees could be required. She outlined the existing landscaping on Ms. Lister's property. Commissioner Brown discussed the existing home on the corner lot, mature landscaping and reduced windows on the proposed development. He discussed the Ponderosa homes and agreed with the proposed two-story homes. He stated he found the architecture appealing and well thought out and designed. He indicated support for the project. Commissioner Gaidos echoed Commissioner Brown. He stated he could not come up with any reason to deny the project. He commended the architect and property owner for their design and consideration of the neighbors. Commissioner Nibert echoed the other Commissioners and stated the letters of opposition were not persuasive given the findings. He indicated support for the project. Commissioner Allen concurred with the previous comments and stated she found the design attractive and believed it enhanced the neighborhood. Chair Pace expressed his gratitude to those who submitted comments on both sides and indicated support of the project. Commissioner Brown moved to approve P21-0132, P21-0133, and PUD-142 as submitted. Commissioner Allen seconded the motion. ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES: Commissioners Allen, Brown, Gaidos, Nibert, and Pace NOES: None ABSENT: Commissioner Morgan ABSTAIN: None Resolution PC-2022-02, approving Case P21-0132, P21-0133, and PUD-142 was adopted as motioned. Commissioner Morgan joined the meeting via Zoom. 7. Continued from December 8, 2021 - P20-1053, Hanna Naguib LLC, 218 Ray Street — Application for Design Review to construct a new 1,069 square-foot two-story residential unit behind an existing commercial building located at 218 Ray Street. Zoning is C-C (Central-Commercial) District Associate Planner Megan Campbell presented the specifics of the item in the Agenda Report. Commissioner Gaidos asked about the parking in-lieu fee. Ms. Campbell explained that the current lot had 10 spaces but was being reconfigured to have 11 spaces, plus an upper lift space. She stated the in-lieu fee was to cover the 12th space because the lift could not be counted. Planning Commission Minutes Page 4 of 9 January 12, 2022 port of the project and discussed efforts to retain the privacy of the neighbors. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED In response to Commissioner Nibert, Ms. Amos discussed the setbacks. Chair Pace asked to see a view of the proposed landscaping between the proposed and existing lot. Ms. Amos displayed the landscape plan and proposed landscaping between the Planning Commission Minutes Page 3 of 9 January 12, 2022 e meeting, such as reducing the amount of testimony time allotted to the applicant and all those who wish to speak when the meeting agenda is lengthy or when there are numerous speakers for any specific item.The audience is requested to respect and extend courtesy to all those wishing to testify on all cases by being quiet while others are speaking. **************************************