PC 091212 - Laserfiche WebLink

a lot more to it than that, including the Downtown Specific Plan District and the Downtown Revitalization District. He added that there are certain references in the document that talk about this specific plan area and revitalization area, and without a map, it might be difficult to know really what is being talked about. Mr. Hosterman pointed out that another item PDA changed is the dBA level from 60 to 70. He noted that the current level is 70 dBA, and the Task Force's recommendation reduced it to 60 dBA. He stated that PDA thinks it is appropriate to take it back to where it was before. Mr. Hosterman encouraged the Commission to adopt the Task Force's recommendations in the Guidelines with the changes proposed by the PDA and EVC and PDA. He stated that he thinks it will make the Downtown a better and more active place with more things to do. He noted that some restaurants have already started this, such as Lokanta, which has a happy hour from 9:30 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. Commissioner Pearce inquired, just from a process perspective, if the PDA evaluation stemmed from the fact that the two PDA representatives on the Task Force voted against the Task Force recommendation. Mr. Hosterman clarified that the two PDA representatives voted in favor of the Task Force recommendation. Commissioner Pearce then inquired if the PDA nevertheless decided to issue its end recommendation. Mr. Hosterman said yes. He explained that what the PDA came up with did not substantively change the Task Force's recommendations but just clarified them. He noted that most of the changes were just minor such as changing "Guidelines" to "Policies." With respect to the dBA level, he stated that the PDA was concentrating more on increasing it to 74 dBA without looking at what the current level was. He added that the 60 dBA was the level at certain times of the day. Scott Raty, Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce, stated that with respect to the decibel levels, he believed there was some confusion even within the Task Force as to whether the new standard would be lowered to 60 dBA from the current standard of 70 dBA. He indicated that in truth, the real problem he has with the Task Force report is that it needs a warning label on it that says, "Caution: delving too deeply into the minutia of decibel ratings will cause dizziness and confusion." He noted that a lot of time was spent on this by a lot of hard - working and conscientious people who did a great job of getting into the detail, and over time, some Task Force members may express some of that confusion as to whether that final number was 60 dBA or 70 dBA. He stated that the current standard is 70 dBA and that it was his understanding that nobody involved from the PDA ever wanted to see that standard lowered from 70 dBA to 60 dBA and that it was their understanding that it would not be. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, September 12, 2012 Page 16 of 35