CCMIN041712 - Laserfiche WebLink

Glen Bunting said he knows the Lopez family personally and while there is a tremendous amount of bickering surrounding the project, it is clear that they are not the only instigators. He stated that the entire purpose of the condition in question was to provide $2,500 for the purchase and installation of a skylight. If, for whatever reason, the Perry's choose not to use the funds for that purpose than it would seem there was not a significant issue to begin with. Helen Sullivant said she originally supported the project because there are several existing two-story homes in the Valdez neighborhood. The City Council made an appropriate decision in supporting mitigation in the form of requiring the applicant to pay $2,500 for the purchase and installation of a skylight. She said she is now baffled that the Perry family is attempting to alter the intent of the condition and troubled that the Lopez family may be the victims of discrimination. Martha DeJesus stated that the condition, as presented today, does in fact differ from what was agreed upon at the last Council meeting. She hoped the Council would recognize the discrepancy and correct the language to provide for payment of a skylight and installation only. She recommended further modification to ensure that the installation is completed before the Lopez family releases any funds. Marthel Green said this is clearly more than a neighborhood squabble and, in looking at the information, it appears that this could be a matter of racial discrimination. He said he attended previous meetings on the matter, knows what was agreed to and was very concerned to see that things may have changed. James Veet said he has known the Lopez family for eight years and that the claims of bullying are out of character for whom he knows them to be. Mayor Hosterman closed the public hearing. Councilmember Cook-Kallio said she was disappointed to see such animosity and predicted this was costing everyone involved much more than money. Staff is clear in that it was their intent that $2,500 would cover the cost of the skylight. It is unfortunate that bids were not procured ahead of time and that likely highlights the need for effective language. She felt the intent was for the Perry's to get a skylight and said she could support staff's Option 1. In lieu of that, she would support Option 3. Councilmember McGovern referred to the photo provided by Mr. Person and said that if accurate, it clearly demonstrates why she did not vote in support of the project. She felt that the lone tree looked like little more than a shrub against the massive backdrop of the Lopez home. She said there has been a clear impact to the Perry's home and that she would support asking the Lopez family to pay the full price of the skylight or allowing the Perry's to use the funds for additional landscaping. Mayor Hosterman cautioned that one of the hazards of coming back before the Council is that the outcome can change significantly. She said she would be in favor of requiring the Lopez family to pay the full cost of the skylight plus an additional $1,000 for landscaping. Councilmember Thorne said this is one of the most difficult types of issues for the Council to deal with, primarily because legislative bodies of this nature are not prepared to resolve the kind of allegations being tossed around. He felt that because the issue was so contentious the Council should stick to the original language of the condition, which to him says that the $2,500 is not earmarked for anything specific. He said he could not support any of the recommended amendments and would vote to deny the appeal. Councilmember Sullivan read the condition, as presented on page 2 of the staff report, and interpreted it to mean that the payment is contingent upon the installation of the skylight. He agreed that the Perry's have suffered but said the Council needs to take some responsibility for approving the project. He felt it would be going too far to extract more money from the Lopez family to provide additional mitigations for City Council Minutes Page 12 of 13 April 17, 2012