CCMIN071911 - Laserfiche WebLink

The public hearing was closed. Councilmember Thome thanked the task force, the Planning and Housing Commissions, the two Councilmember participants and staff. He supports staff recommendations including the Planning Commission and Housing Commission changes which are recommended by staff, is amenable to adding back 30 units per acre for CM Capital, supports submitting the entire package to HCD with the understanding the Council will never have to zone more than what it is required to by law, and is interested in submitting more than the required number of acres due to not knowing what HCD will do. If the City should receive an approval for more than what is needed, it would be his objective to rezone only the amount the City is required to and to balance that burden throughout the community. He said he wants to ensure the City does not overburden any single neighborhood or area of the community with inconveniences that higher density populations bring. Regarding items to be sent to the growth management committee, he is a member along with Councilmember McGovern, and he will do the best he can to put into the plan what the community wants and what he feels are in the best interests of the community. He thinks that the bottom line is that the citizens of the community and the City Council no longer control land use planning in Pleasanton. The fact is that the State legislature, via ABAG and MTC, using RHNA, AB32, and SB375 control land use and they will soon be telling the City where it must build units. It is more interesting that no one ever elected these individuals to do land use planning in Pleasanton, and he is saddened that it is not only land use. He commented that the City received a list of 13 new bills that take more control over local issues from the hands of citizens and puts them into the hands of the State legislature or other regional governmental agencies. Examples include limiting the City's ability to contract out staffing, which should be a local decision and another attempts to mandate State intervention into local financial and labor disputes. He suggested everybody letting their legislators know that we want to control issues that are rightfully ours to control. MOTION: It was moved by Councilmember Thorne to direct staff to make changes as made by the Planning Commission and Housing Commission, to return the CM Capital Site 13 designation to 30 units per acre, and submit the Draft Housing Element of the General Plan to the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) for review Councilmember McGovern supported the 23 units and 30 units per acre for the CM Capital site, as it provides a better perspective in working with 2 and 3 stories and 3 and 4 stories on the site of 12.6 acres which will allow for a better streetscape and massing. Councilmember Thorne acknowledged Councilmember McGovern's comments stating he knows there are some drawbacks to it. His intent is to submit the maximum number so that what returns will have the maximum amount of flexibility. Councilmember Cook-Kallio echoed Councilmember Thorne's comments, thanked everybody for their work, and felt the process was educational and helpful. She voiced the importance of having El Charro and Stanley Boulevard and said it is the Council's responsibility to do this sooner rather than later. Regarding schools, people want to live in Pleasanton because people value the education here. She and Councilmember Thorne sit on the liaison committee with the school district. She assured the public that planning for students is on everybody's minds, and they will have to accommodate whatever numbers of students live in the area. In terms of the CM Properties, she is inclined to send them to HCD at 30 units per acre. She supports the Auf de Maur/Richenback Meyer Site 8 being at the higher density with the caveat that all of this density should not be put in the east side of Pleasanton. She would be happier if there were conversations about a park, but thinks without the retail and a balance throughout the City, she City Council Minutes Page 12 of 14 July 19,2011