24 - Laserfiche WebLink

Mr. Spangler asked about the opaque glass being changed to clear glass. Ms. Leroudier mentioned that there is a state law that homeowners have the right to use and enjoy their property with the exclusion of others. She stated that if they cannot install this window then their rights are not being protected. Ms. Leroudier stated that other cities all around Pleasanton do not have this law that you must get the neighbor's permission to install a second -story window. She mentioned that this was a waste of time and taxpayers money and does not agree with Pleasanton's law. She also mentioned that this process damages relationships with the neighbors. The Public Hearing was closed. Ms. Stern explained that a lot of information was brought up yesterday about the area and the conditions on the site, but noted that the discussion today had revolved around the privacy issue and what people's expectation of what privacy is. She stated that she went to visit the site to evaluate some of that information and to figure out what would be the reasonable expectation for privacy in that neighborhood, given the conditions, and the houses and changes that people have made to their houses and to the'.r sites, including the applicant, the neighbor and the other houses around there. Ms. Stern noted that after visiting the area she noticed that people have made additions to their houses and that many balconies do look into neighboring yards. She stated that she understands the concern about viewing into the living area, but there are ways to prevent that by using blinds. She noted her concern regarding the exterior area because there is not an opportunity to put a tree there or increase the fence height to maintain the privacy. She noted the raised deck in the neighboring yard that gives them the opportunity to look into the applicant's yard pretty clearly. She also noted the neighbor's window additions that look over onto the applicant's home and the other neighbor. Ms. Stern mentioned her concern with opaque glass because that could cause more issues. She noted the window will be opened at certain times and they could also replace the glass without going through a review by the City. She stated that it would be hard to enforce that condition of only installing opaque glass. Ms. Stern noted that she will make a decision today that will end this process, but she hopes the neighbors will adapt to this anc. keep a neighbor relationship as that is more important than a window. The Zoning Administrator granted approval of PADR -2138, subject to the conditions of approval as shown on the attached Exhibit B. Respectfully submitted, Natalie Amos PADR -2138, Leroudier December 22, 2010