PC 07/14/99 - Laserfiche WebLink

Mr. Swirl referenced a staff report dated July 14, 1999, and highlighted key areas contained in the report including background information, site design and development standards, building design, parking and driveways, landscaping and grading. In conclusion, Mx. Swift noted that staffs recommendation is that the Commission adopt a resolution approving Case Z-99-175 subject to Exhibit "B," Draft Conditions of Approval. Chief Stewart Gary of the Livermore-Pleasanton Fire Department, provided an overview of the project including size and location of buildings and growth issues. In conclusion, he noted that the building is aesthetically pleasing and meets the needs of the community with limited expandability. Discussion ensued relating to the facility on Vineyard Avenue, description of the property line, distance from fuel tanks to the Arroyo, and noise levels and size of generators. PUBLIC HEARING WAS OPENED Frank Auf der Maur, 4558 Bemal Avenue, commented on the design of the east side of building being a solid wall. Chief Gary noted that the existing cave line for the expansion dormitory would be removed and a false eave line would be utilized to add dimension to the solid wall. Further, that an antique hose cart and antique bells from the two cities would be displayed at the project. PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED Commissioner Sullivan commented on the great design of the building and stated that there is a need in the commtmity for this facility. However, he expressed concern with noise levels from generators and alarms for residents adjacent to the Arroyo and the proximity of the fuel tank to the arroyo. Commissioner Sullivan noted that due to fuel spills that could occur, he would be in favor of relocating fuel tanks away from the Arroyo. Discussion ensued relating to the triangular shape of the property, fire codes applicable to fuel tanks, installation of a three-sided containment wall versus a wrought-iron fence, and devices that could be utilized to prevent spills. Commissioner Sullivan noted he would vote in support of project if there was a containment wall on the back side of fuel tank closer to the Arroyo to prevent fuel spills from nmning into the Arroyo. Chief Gary noted that staff would be willing to explore significant secondary containment measures on the fuel facility with staff examining the possibility of a containment wall, curb height, and a positive latching system for fuel hoses. Commissioner Maas commented on the design of the project and noted she would vote in support of the project. PLANNiNG COMMISSION MINUTES Page 9 July 14, 1999