Appendix D - Cultural and Tribal Cultural Resources Supporting Information PUBLIC

DPR 523L (1/95) State of California – The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page 3 of 12 Resource Name or #: 11021 and 11033 Dublin Canyon Road Recorded by Ward Hill Date: April 2018 Continuation Update P3a. Description, con’t 11021 Dublin Canyon Road A driveway leads from the street to a parking area on the west side of the house at 11021 Dublin Canyon Road. A modern aluminum frame carport is at the southwest corner of the house. The house at 11021 Dublin Canyon Road has an enclosed side yard on the east and a small vegetable garden enclosed by a chain link fence in front of the house. The landscaping adjacent to the two houses includes various shrubs, a lawn, an open grassy area and a variety of small and medium size trees. A redwood tree is adjacent to the rear of the house at 11021 Dublin Canyon Road. Thick ivy covers the wall at the base of the recessed porch at 11021 Dublin Canyon Road. The Bungalow Style house at 11021 Dublin Canyon Road is a single-family, single-story house. The house has a moderately pitched cross-gable roof covered with asphalt shingles and patched with rolled roofing paper. The house has exterior stucco walls. The roof has wide eaves with exposed rafters. The front and side (west) gables also have prominent eave brackets. The large projecting front gable covers the entrance porch on the western half of the front façade. Three steps lead up to the raised entrance porch. The prominent wide porch wraps around from the front (north) façade around to the west façade. The five square, evenly spaced porch columns set on a low wall are faced with clinker brick. The windows in the house are primarily wood-sash double-hung or casement. The front façade has a tripartite window (narrow side windows flank a wider center window) left of the entrance door. A stucco covered chimney penetrates the roof porch on the west facade. Inside, the small house has six rooms. The compact square plan with 904 square feet (about 30 by 30 feet) has no interior hallways. The rooms open directly one to another. The front door opens directly into the living room on the west side of the north facade. The living room has a coffered ceiling, wood wainscoting, a built-in break front with leaded glass doors and a fireplace faced with clinker brick (now painted). The doors and windows are framed with plain boards. The kitchen is south of and adjacent to the living room. The eastern half of the interior includes two small bedrooms (with bathroom in between) and a utility room. A kitchen door on the west leads to the side porch. A rear door from the utility room leads to the back yard. The condition of the house appears to be poor and deteriorated. The porch is tilting to the west away from house. The ends of the roof rafters are rotted. The roof has been patched in several locations. The sagging west slope of the roof suggests the building may have significant structural deficiencies. 11033 Dublin Canyon Road A gravel driveway east of the house leads to an attached carport at 11033 Dublin Canyon Road. The Ranch House Style house at 11033 Dublin Canyon Road is single-family, single-story house with an L-shaped plan. The cross gable roof (covered with asphalt shingles) has plain shallow eaves. The exterior walls are covered with smooth stucco. The windows on the front façade are horizontal aluminum sash sliders. The front (north) façade has a prominent gable on the west with an adjacent recessed entrance porch. The gable has wide eaves with decorative brackets; the wall below the gable has two aluminum frame windows. The front façade has a brick base. One square post supports the porch roof projecting out from the main gable roof. The south façade has a sliding glass rear door. Inside, the house has 1,850 square feet. The four bedrooms are on the west with the living areas - a kitchen, a dining room and a family room – on the east. The interior walls are largely covered wallboard. Part of the family room has natural wood paneling. B10. Significance, con’t The 240 acre parcel was not subdivided until the mid-20th century. Michael Devany also owned a 309 acre parcel east of the town of Dublin. Devany and his wife Mary had six children, two sons and four daughters (Lynch 2007:41). Mary Devany died in 1881 at age 45 and Michael Devany died in 1890 at age 73 (Lynch 2007:41). The Devany’s youngest daughter, Eliza, inherited the 240 acre parcel on Dublin Canyon Road. Eliza married a San Francisco Police Officer, John W. Butterworth, in 1891. Eliza and John Butterworth lived in San Francisco on Folsom Street (1900 U.S. Census). The Official Maps of Alameda County of 1900 and 1907 shows “Eliza Butterfield” as the owner of the 240 acre parcel purchased by her father. Given that she and her husband did not live on the property, it is likely they rented it to a tenant farmer, possibly occupied by a farm manager. John Butterfield died 1908, however his wife Eliza lived in San Francisco until 1949 (Lynch 2007:101). Eliza Butterfield apparently sold the 240 acre Dublin property soon after her husband’s death. The 1910 and 1915 Official Map of Alameda County shows J. V. Fernandos as the owner of the 240 acre parcel. According to 1910 United States Census, “Joseph V. Fernandes”, a farmer age 43, lived on the Dublin Pass Road with wife Mary (age 28). The names are often misspelled on the Alameda County Official Maps (which show property ownership). The person listed in the Census is likely the same person shown as the property owner J.V. Fernandos. According to the Census, Joseph Fernandes immigrated from Portugal in 1883 and he had been married 13 years. He is shown as the owner of the property where he and his wife resided. The Alameda County Assessor Records indicate a 1918 construction for the Bungalow Style house (11033 Dublin Canyon Road) extant today on the property, thus its likely Joseph Fernandes built this house. A detached garage originally adjacent to the rear of the house has been removed (Kolb 2018). Historical archives did not indicate clearly how long Fernandes resided on this property. □