CCMIN080503 - Laserfiche WebLink

Mr. Brozosky supported the Library Commission requests, but not the staff recommendation 2 because it goes beyond the Commission recommendations. He did not feel Council should endorse that. Mayor Pico invited public testimony. Michael Bischoff, 7609 Landale Avenue, Dublin, felt this issue involved all the citizens of the United States as well as elected Boards and City Councils. He wanted to preserve the U.S. Constitution and to speak for all those who have fought to defend it. Council was elected to be the voice of the people and not just set policy, hire the City Manager and oversee City business. The oath of office included defending the Constitution. He urged Council to support the Library Commission and also to denounce the Patriot Act. Vanessa Kawaihau, 871 Sycamore Road, thanked the Library Commission for taking the action it did and she thanked Council for allowing the Commission to consider political issues. She related an incident when she was in school when lockers were searched and books removed. She noted the titles and subjects of some of the books. That changed how she purchased or checked out books. She felt it was important to stop the government from affecting the library. Nancy Freedom, 5130 Case Avenue #C-103, indicated she had been a librarian for many years in various libraries across the country. Citizens' concerns about the Patriot Act have raised a groundswell of protest from over 135 municipalities. She is contacting her representatives at all levels. The Constitution says citizens can petition the government with grievances. That does not mean just the Federal government. She urged Council to adopt option 3 in the staff report. Thomas Jefferson said "The field of knowledge is the common property of mankind". She wanted to keep knowledge as free as possible. Paulette Salisbury, 6170 Corte Trancas, said that since the tragedy of September 11, there have been many slogans. Some fill us with pride; some chill us. At this meeting we are talking about the Freedom to Read Act and who would ever have thought that would occur. She supported the Library Commission in defense of the Constitution. The Commissioners have taken time to inform themselves and research the issue and be active U.S. citizens. She strongly supported their actions and urged Council to support Option 3. Paulette Kenyon, 6842 Adobe Court, presented a quotation from the book "The Middle Mind, Why Americans Don't Think for Themselves". Basically, it claimed most people defer their opinions to others in prominent positions. This is a failure born of lack of imagination. Fortunately, there are those with imagination. She was thankful the Library Commission felt this was matter not to be deferred. She applauded them for taking a stand to protect the citizens and the Constitution and taking the time to inform themselves. She urged Council to honor its citizens and the Commission by supporting the actions of the Commission as set forth in Option 3. Pat Murray, 4470 Mirador Drive, referred to comments from those who say it is not the business of the Council to take a stand against the Patriot Act because it would not have much Pleasanton City Council 18 08/05/03 Minutes