SR 05:258 - Laserfiche WebLink

homes would have the same design elements; he suggested that the roof pitches be varied somewhat. He encouraged the design to be more home-like, rather than just a house. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. In response to an inquiry by Commissioner Arkin about whether Larry Cannon reviewed this project, Ms. Decker replied that this application was not peer-reviewed, although several iterations of the materials and elevations were reviewed. She noted that there was variation in the fa~ade treatment. In response to an inquiry by Commissioner Arkin on whether the Housing Commission examined such infill projects for affordable housing and whether it considered this particular project, Ms. Decker replied that this particular project was not required to have inclusionary housing and that it met the affordability-by-design criterion. Commissioner Fox noted that she liked this design, especially the symmetry and variation in housing materials, and that she would support this project. Chairperson Maas noted that she did not object to the tandem parking and was concerned about the loss of sky view. Commissioner Blank expressed concern about density and believed the home designs were not distinct enough for his taste. Commissioner Roberts believed that the roof slopes were too similar, and she did not like the carport at the duplex. Chairperson Maas suggested that the item be continued so the applicant may work with staffto fine-tune the issues and design. Commissioner Maas moved to continue this item and refer it to staff for further modification. Commissioner Blank seconded the motion. Commissioner Arkin expressed concern about the number of homes on a quarter-acre lot. He would support a peer review of this project. Chairperson Maas agreed that a peer review would be beneficial. Commissioner Blank agreed with Commissioner Roberts' sensitivity toward affordable or achievable housing, which may be gained by using altemative designs. He believed the roof slopes and duplex parking should be examined more closely. He believed the garages should be set for parking only and that any trees that are destroyed should be replaced in addition to the payment of a mitigation fee. Commissioner Roberts noted that she had spoken to Mike Fulford about the black walnut, and Mr. Fulford stated that while the tree could be trimmed, the black walnuts near California EXCERPTS: PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES, May 11,2005 Page 4 of5