02 - Laserfiche WebLink

In response to Councilmember Testa's inquiry, Police Chief Swing reported the carotid restraint hold is temporarily suspended because its use is currently being reviewed in state legislation. He noted it is a temporary suspension and not a ban as he wanted to provide the opportunity for thoughtful reflection on that before making a permanent decision. City Manager Fialho reported an upcoming staff report will include a review of state and federal legislation that has passed or is in process of being debated for City Council review. He noted City Council will have an opportunity to define the process over the next three months but noted the City is constrained by state and federal law. Councilmember Testa requested staff provide a review of oversight roles of City Council for the PPD. PUBLIC COMMENT Mayor Thorne opened the item for Public Comment. John Sensiba expressed support for PPD but expressed concern that conversations to defund the police at a national level could be impacting conversations at a local level. He encouraged funding for mental health and other social services in Pleasanton. Aryan Ohri suggested increased police training, encouraged demilitarization of PPD, increased transparency, and more comprehensive background checks for police officers. Brad Hirst encouraged City Council to provide oversight to PPD and provide a sufficient budget to fund the department. He encouraged Police Chief Swing to hire only the best qualified and capable police officers. Steve Van Dorn, Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce, expressed support for PPD and encouraged City Council to adopt the 3-Step Action Plan Jill Buck recalled a positive interaction with police officers and expressed support for PPD. Paul Martens expressed support for PPD, opposes defunding of the police budget, and defaming of PPD. In response to Mr. Marten's previous comments, Councilmember Brown clarified her initial comments regarding her opposition to defunding PPD. Nadia Rehman encouraged City Council to ban no-knock police raids, change the use of force standards from reasonable to necessary, commit to not hiring police officers who were previously dismissed for serious misconduct, require mandatory blood and alcohol tests within one-hour of an officer-involved shooting, require independent autopsy for the deceased in officer-involved shootings, eliminate policers officer's ability to review evidence such as their bodycams, and prohibit destruction of personnel files and complaints. Arne Olson expressed support for PPD, contributed Pleasanton's low crime rate to good policing, expressed support for additional training for police officers, and expressed opposition to defunding the police. Ward Kanowsky encouraged City Council to review procedural change within the PPD and expressed support for the reallocation of funding towards mental health services. Nick Gonella suggested City Council consider adding a request for an independent review of PPD as part of the overall review, supports reallocating funds towards mental health professionals, and encouraged City Council to complete their review as soon as possible. City Council Minutes Page 3 of 7 July 14, 2020