PC 011520 - Laserfiche WebLink

Ms. Seto referenced a recent sting in August 2019 and indicated that four of the 20+ businesses were not compliant. Chair Ritter inquired about theft and use of fake identification. He thanked the Youth Commission for its involvement. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS OPENED Resident of Livermore Kyoko Takayama addressed the Commission regarding the epidemic of vaping and the impact on her six grandchildren. She referenced the moral issue behind the sale of tobacco, regardless of whether it was legal. Tobacco Control Program Director of Alameda County Public Health Official Paul Cummings explained that clerks would be fined if there was no retail licensing. He stated an ordinance would provide the City with the ability to set appropriate penalties. He discussed the exemption in the City of Oakland for adult only retailers. He thanked the Planning Commission for its consideration and the Youth Commission for its input. Representative from Breathe California Audrey Abadilla shared studies and evidence pertaining to buffers and health risks with tobacco sales and use. Amy Shannon spoke as a parent and public health professional regarding tobacco use and the ease of access to tobacco products for underage youth. She encouraged the use of a buffer and to honor the recommendations of the Youth Commission. She suggested consideration of enforcement mechanisms and reminded the Commission of the City's goal to promote healthy community. Rosalyn Moya referenced the 1,000-foot buffer and density pertaining to deciding the bigger distance. She referenced the tobacco use licenses and demonstrated various product packaging and marketing geared towards youth. Pleasanton Resident Helena Jin spoke regarding the Youth Commission's study that 74 percent of youth obtained tobacco products through a retail store. She referenced the numbers of youth playing in the parks or at recreation facilities each day. She suggested the City of Pleasanton act, like the neighboring cities adopting ordinances. Jannell Gladen, mother to two teen boys and Tri-Valley resident, discussed her work in schools and with youth. She stated her son began vaping between fifth and sixth grade. She suggested limiting access to youth, to help curb usage. She expressed concern with the visibility of advertisements for tobacco and vape products. She suggested the City have consistent policies with surrounding cities. Kristie Wang, mother of two teenage children, referenced the effect of the ordinance passed by the City of Livermore, which became effective January 1, 2020. She discussed enforcement and the support and advocacy of the Livermore Police Department. She stated youth were going to other cities to get their products. Planning Commission Minutes Page 5 of 11 January 15, 2020