CCMIN08212018 - Laserfiche WebLink

outdoors. He added the facility is 50 yards from Hopyard Road, it will never be quiet, and the City is being over restrictive. Joe Streng stated with new religious organization designations, he believed it is appropriate to revise the regulations noting they seem to be overly restrictive for the Chabad. He reported it is not unreasonable for the Chabad to expect to be treated like other religious organizations in the City and commended the work done to reach a compromise. Marilou West reported for eight years Rabbi Resnick held the Chabad at his home and, although she is pleased the two parties were able to reach a compromise, for eight years she and her neighbors were ignored and terrorized with parking problems and noise. She opined the events will be much larger than originally proposed and referenced a letter from her neighbors listing their concerns. Greg Goldman reported he is Russian and Jewish and that his parents were never able to perform a Bar Mitzvah for him, but thanks to Chabad, he was able to perform one for his son. He did not believe the City should impose restrictions on events, especially during the day. Neal Neuman, Director of Security for Chabad Tri-Valley, commented on his experience in security and security training and noted there has been a lot of good coming out of the contentious process. He commented on the building of trust and commended the Chabad and the Millers for reaching a compromise. He hoped Council will approve the project, so they can get to work. James Schwartz, Attorney for the Chabad Tri-Valley, reported he is not a member of the Chabad, but he is a member of the community and believes in what they are trying to do. He commented positively on the parties reaching a compromise and addressed the protection of land use as a religious exercise, noting it was enacted into law so that communities could not shut out religious organizations in their neighborhoods. He questioned the City's rationale for restricting the number of people in an area to 24 especially if that area is over 150 feet from adjacent neighbors. This is a condition the Chabad is not willing to accept and puts a substantial burden on its religious rights. He expressed the same concerns regarding limiting the number of the indoor congregation to 120 people and listed lawsuits which the Chabad was successful in winning. He opined the City must look at this matter as a religious use, not as a land use. Mr. Miller commented on the compromises they have reached with Chabad and encouraged Council to look at the agreement and approve everything Council thinks is reasonable and fair. He stated the only issues in which they differ are related to the 120 people on the terrace and the 24 people in the patio area and suggested that while the door is open for expanding the use of those areas, let the operation get into full swing and reevaluate the matter after there has been some experience and move slowly, with caution. Mrs. Miller said the Chinese Church referenced is in a commercial area, noted ordinances are less restrictive than in a residential area and is not relevant. She reported giving huge concessions to Rabbi Resnick in the negotiations, specifically in regard to the use of the back yard. She noted she has a petition of 25 neighbors all of whom stated they do not want any use around the area. She added they did not ask their attorney to the meeting tonight because they thought they had reached a compromise. She asked the City Council to maintain the 15 annual events, the 24 people on the patio area, the 120 people per event and the additional sound- barrier fencing. Mayor Thorne reported receiving documents today at 4:30 p.m. and asked staff if they have enough information, at this point, to advise the City Council on this matter. City Council Minutes Page 6 of 10 August 21, 2018