11 - Laserfiche WebLink

Commissioner Brown concluded he believed the applicant addressed the concerns laid out at the workshop, maybe not to the extent the Commission expected, but they did. He asked any Commissioner in favor of denial be specific in their comments to the applicant on what they would like to see revised in the event the applicant chooses to come back with revised plans. Commissioner Nagler responded to Commissioner Brown's request, explaining how one of the requests made at the workshop was to reach out to the neighborhood to see if they could gain some support for the revised design. He affirmed the application is still opposed by neighbors, and while their concerns may not bei in the purview of the Commission, they suggest the applicant did not try to gain support from their neighbors. Commissioner Nagler pointed out the other comments madc)tonight were in line with what was previously requested at the workshop. Commissioner Allen added that massing was a concern shared bythe Commission at the workshop and while the applicant had made progress, she= sand others have expressed concern tonight that the massing and 'FAR is still out of pro ortion for the neighborhood. k �,c Chair Balch remarked while the Commission has'asked other applicants at other times to speak to their neighbors and sometimes they do and'sometimes they don't, his belief is that his neighbor does not have therright to tell him what he can or cannot do with his property. Chair Balch elaborated, explaining}his intention with that comment was to bridge the harmony as a community of characters and 'n44.19 gain full support of the proposed design. Chair Balch stated he supported staff's recommendation. Commissioner Ritter movedto deny Case P17-0372. Commissioner Allen seconded the motion s ROLL CALL VOTE.}� F AYES� ' t Commissioners Allen, Nagler, and Ritter 'NOES: " t Commissioners Balch and O'Connor ABSTAIN: None 'kRECUSED None 'tABSENT: None Resolution PC-2017-17 denying Case P17-0372 was entered and adopted as motioned. r EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, August 23, 2017 Page 4 of 4