PC 031214 - Laserfiche WebLink

C. Are the building designs, massing, heights, and colors and materials acceptable and compatible with the surrounding area? Commissioner Pearce stated that she thinks this has really been thoughtfully done and is compatible. She noted that she likes the colors and the architecture. Commissioner Allen concurred that it was thoughtfully done and that she likes it as well Commissioner Olson agreed Commissioner O'Connor stated that he knows there are concerns about three stories, but the City is trying to provide the units that are needed, and this is the only way to do it with a beautiful garden -style look. He noted that that was the biggest concern with the Pleasanton Gardens area, keeping that "cottage" look. He stated that it was been done with a lot of thought and that he think it is beautiful. Commissioner Ritter concurred and added that the lobby area for social gatherings is a thought. Commissioner Posson stated that it is very nicely done. D. Is the proposed tree removal /replacement plan acceptable? Commissioner Posson stated he thinks it is fine. He indicated that the development needs to be accommodated, and he does not see any other alternatives at this point. Commissioner Ritter agreed and added that the type of trees should be thoroughly thought out so residents do not stumble. Commissioner O'Connor stated that mention was made about the possibility of saving a couple more heritage trees if something were done with the roundabout. He noted that if someone made the wrong entrance and did not want to be at this particular place, the roundabout can certainly help in getting turned around. He added that he does not know if there is also a use for parking along that roundabout, particularly as it leads to the common area building and to Mid Pen Housing's offices. He suggested that the developer take another look if there is any way to save additional heritage trees. Chair Olson stated that he is fine with the tree plan Commissioner Allen stated that she is also fine with the plan but would like the developer to take a look at whether there is a way to save a couple more heritage trees. Commissioner Pearce agreed, stating that she always hate taking out trees, but she thinks it is necessary. She noted, however, that the staff report did indicate that trees 165 and 164, which are Coast Live Oaks, could be preserved, and she supports that. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, March 12, 2014 Page 19 of 24