16 - Laserfiche WebLink

alleviating their pain when they have an asthma attack. She indicated that if she cannot have a balcony on the house, then the house can stay the way it is because it does not make sense to her to spend that money if her children cannot have a comfortable house when they are sick. She added that they moved to the area for the good school and the good neighborhood, and they expected that they would have good neighbors and a good support system. She asked the Commissioners to make the right decision and thanked them for their time. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. Acting Chair Ritter stated that it sounds like this is a great neighborhood, and the residents are very cordial with one another. He indicated that he liked hearing people on both sides say they liked this and did not like that, and thanked them for keeping it that way. Acting Chair Ritter stated that the Commission's job it to ensure that the Zoning Code and other codes and laws are followed and that the proposal fits into the neighborhoods properly. He indicated that he has been on the Commission longer than most of the other Commissioners and noted that neighborhood issues are the most difficult cases that the Commission has to deal with, and the Commission wants to do what is best for Pleasanton and the neighborhoods. Commissioner Nagler stated that what is tough about this is that it is all about everybody's children, and every family is in the conversation because of the concern over children's health and privacy. He noted that what causes neighbors and groups of people to get along to the extent possible is compromise, and there has been no ability to compromise in any way on this project, given that everyone's concern is exactly the same heartfelt concern for their children, and the Commission will have to make a decision and choose the concern of one child over that of another. He added that it is a complete shame because the Commission is just not in a position to decide whether the totally legitimate concern of a family that their teenage daughter's privacy be properly maintained is more or less important than where the cool air is acquired for a child in the middle of an asthma attack. He stated that it is not a pleasant task and that does not think that it should be an appropriate task for the Commission when the people who are directly impacted should themselves be able to come up with a compromise. Commissioner Piper agreed that this is a difficult decision to make. She indicated that these are the Planning Commission meetings that she does not like to come to and prefers making decisions on what is being built Downtown on Main Street. She stated that she knows the Birdland area well and is quite intimately familiar with it because she grew up there. She indicated that they had a pool and all the children were in the pool, and privacy was not an issue for them back then. She added that they had second stories and people looked down, and all the children were friends and knew one another. She stated that she cannot resonate with the issues at hand relating to the children, because if the child has asthma and the proper solution is to go outside, there are many different ways to go outside other than through a balcony. She added that EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES, May 27, 2015 Page 8 of 14