16 - Laserfiche WebLink

Mr. Cummings stated that he went and surveyed about 80 houses, all the two-story houses that are on and around Hummingbird Road and in Pleasanton Valley, and he could not verify a rear-facing balcony on any of the Morrison-built homes. He pointed out that a mulberry tree is a deciduous tree, which becomes a skeleton in the winter time, as shown in a slide presented by staff. He noted that one can see right through that tree, and the privacy views are actually going to be more compromised. He added that the biggest issue with trying to provide organic screening is that organic screening is not like a fence: if a fence falls down, it can be remediated in one day; but if a tree breaks, it cannot be fixed overnight and will have to grow back. He pointed out that the trees grow one to two feet a year, and it would need another ten feet of growth to achieve full privacy screening from the proposed balcony. He stated that he owned a house with 21 Cypress trees and when they are spaced apart, they provide a space in between, through which one can see and which would compromise one's privacy. Mr. Cummings stated that he has a household of three women, his two daughters and his wife, and they enjoy the backyard all the time. He noted that they have a really strong community, and his neighbors would potentially be affected by this if they come to his house and go in the backyard. He indicated that he canvassed the neighborhood and surveyed about 32 houses along the Sandpiper Way loop and received overwhelming support from them. He stated that some people could not make it to tonight's meeting, but most of those present tonight support him. He added that some of them sent emails. On another issue, Mr. Cummings stated that he built a common fence between their properties and had requested Ms. Kisiloglu to treat her side of the fence. He indicated that instead of doing so, she planted these four trees against the fence which would deteriorate the fence. Mr. Cummings stated that it comes down to a matter of whether they feel there is privacy or not, whether they feel good about being in their backyard. He indicated that if there is somebody lingering on the porch for some reason, he cannot ensure that his wife and daughters will feel comfortable in the pool or in the hot tub or just enjoy the backyard, as they will actually potentially be a direct view. He stated that when they bought this house, they wanted a house with a pool; they wanted a place where they can enjoy things and spend a lot of time out in their backyard. He noted that they have a sound system out there so they can enjoy the summer when the weather gets better and really try and feel comfortable. He added that they now have had very nice neighbors who have moved in and have never made them feel like their privacy is compromised; but now his wife feels like she is violated and is very uncomfortable all the time about the thought that something like this is going to happen. Mr. Cummings stated that he understands it is unfortunate that Ms. Kiziloglu's family has asthma and can only imagine what having an asthma attack feels like. He indicated, however, that he cannot see the need to use asthma to justify having a backyard patio when one can simply open a window for fresh air. He then stated that EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES, May 27, 2015 Page 2 of 14