01 - Laserfiche WebLink

of them has sworn to uphold the law including those that they may not like. While she as an individual can make the choice to act differently and face the consequences, that same choice as a member of the Council means that every citizen must face those consequences. Therefore, as a member of the Council she does not have the luxury of advocating as she might as an individual. She discussed her involvement on the last Housing Element Task Force and while it was a difficult and often uncomfortable process, it ultimately yielded an inventory that spread high-density development throughout the city as fairly as was possible. She said she shared concerns over growth, overcrowding in schools and the demand on resources. However, she pointed out that those same arguments were likely used when the very homes that most of them live in today were developed and the best that anyone can do is to slow development down to the extent that is possible. She said she opposed a change in zoning on the CM Capital 2 site for several reasons — 1) it is crucial to maintain a buffer of very low and low income units; 2) a healthy community has a balance across the full spectrum of housing units, which would be compromised by a down-zoning at this site; 3) the potential precedent. She explained that the Parkside neighborhood and other stakeholders had an opportunity to engage during the last update. While she did recognize and appreciate their willingness to represent their respective interests and reach a compromise, she struggled with the fairness of saying "yes" to this neighborhood while saying "no" to others; and 4) she would be remiss in her representative obligation if she favored one neighborhood over another in terms of balancing the impacts. She felt that to overturn the decisions that resulted from a long and agonizing process was insulting. MOTION: It was moved by Cook-Kallio to approve submittal of the 2015-2023 Draft Housing Element Update to the General Plan to HCD, as amended to reflect the recommendations of the Economic Vitality Committee. Motion died for lack of a second. Vice-Mayor Pentin offered an amendment and second to the motion that was ultimately rejected. He agreed that the last update process was difficult but sound and resulted in a solid document and plan. However, he explained that he would like to support the request to reduce the zoning on the CM Capital 2 site to 12.5 units per acre with the caveat that it revert to its current zoning if HCD were to object. He said that for him it is largely about balance and doing what is right, which is to provide housing of all means. It is the responsibility of this Council to ensure that every member of this town is well represented, including those who may move here in the future. He stressed that affordable housing is about providing for seniors, the workforce and the developmentally disabled. He said that the draft document is literally leveraging the hard work of the previous Housing Element and he sees no reason for significant changes. The data presented tonight demonstrates a pattern of fairness and of slow and smart growth. Councilmember Cook-Kallio said she appreciated the thoughtfulness of his comments. However, she could not support a reduction in zoning because it does nothing to ensure affordable housing and discounts the thoughtfulness with which these housing sites were distributed across the city. MOTION: It was moved by Pentin to approve submittal of the 2015-2023 Draft Housing Element Update to the General Plan to HCD, as amended to reflect the recommendations of the Planning Commission regarding the CM Capital 2 site and Economic Vitality Committee. Motion died for lack of a second. Councilmember Cook-Kallio asked to bifurcate the issues so that she would not be in the position of voting against submittal of the Draft Element. MOTION: It was moved by Pentin to accept the Planning Commission recommendation to rezone the CM Capital 2 site to a density of 12.5 units per acre, with the with the caveat that it revert to its current zoning if HCD were to object. Motion died for lack of a second. City Council Minutes Page 13 of 17 September 2,2014