CCMIN030414 - Laserfiche WebLink

Councilmember Cook-Kallio acknowledged Councilmember Brown's point regarding the General Plan cycle but said she recalled discussing east Pleasanton as part of the previous plan. Mr. Fialho said there was discussion in the 1996 General Plan to plan for the area but more specific discussion in terms of potential outcome and the need for a Specific Plan did not occur until the current General Plan. Councilmember Cook-Kallio asked and staff confirmed that this is essentially the last area of vacant land that would come under a Specific Plan. Vice-Mayor Pentin asked how many residential units were constructed during the last RHNA planning period, though he did acknowledge the economic crisis taking place at the time. Mr. Fialho estimated less than 300 units. Mr. Dolan added that only 20 building permits were issued in 2009. Councilmember Brown noted that the housing cap had not yet been overturned in 2009. She asked whether staff had any indication of close the city is to the 29,000 unit cap at present. Ms. Stern stated there were approximately 26,174 units as of January 1, 2013. With the addition of other pending or mid-construction process developments, the present total would be approximately 28,200. Mayor Thorne opened the public hearing. Rick Irby said he has been a member of the Pleasanton community for 70 years. He said his mother's final request before her passing last year was that the family farm, situated right in the heart of Pleasanton, be developed with housing so that others may benefit from the value of life in Pleasanton. Ingrid Wetmore said she spoke on behalf of residents of the Parkside neighborhood. Given the most recent report outlined the city's revised RHNA obligation for 2014-2022, she requested that the city rezone the remaining half of parcel #9 from the Summerhill development to commercial from residential. She said their neighborhood fully supports delaying completion of the East Pleasanton Specific Plan until after the community can fully evaluate the effects of other approved developments on the city's infrastructure. Mayor Thorne asked when the rezoning issue would come forward to the Council. Mr. Fialho explained that it would come forward as part of the Housing Element update, likely in the October/November timeframe. Kelly Cousins, East Pleasanton Specific Plan Task Force, said that the task force's discussion and ultimate selection of a preferred plan was largely based on RHNA numbers that are no longer relevant. She felt strongly that the community wants smart growth and does not support any more housing than is absolutely necessary. She questioned the wisdom of continuing a process that will ultimately be obsolete. She said she strongly favored postponing completion of the Specific Plan, despite what so many have invested in the process, and urged the Council to support a more cautious approach to development on the east side. Arne Olson said he felt strongly that the planning process should continue as planned. He said that to stop now is disrespectful to all those who have invested significant time and money and sends a message to both the community and the state that is not in keeping with a community of planned progress. He agreed that the community feels the process has moved too quickly and thought that, rather than abandoning the plan, it would be beneficial to slow down and do a more thorough job of outreach and education. He felt particular focus should be given to educating citizens on the role that City Council Minutes Page 7 of 12 March 4, 2014