06 ATTACHMENTS - Laserfiche WebLink

with their existing parking situation and that of their visitors. She urged the Commission to deny the application. Commissioner Olson disclosed that the Shapiros are personal friends of his. Joyce Shapiro stated that she has lived in Pleasanton since 1966 and has driven First Street, Second Street, Neal Street, and the surrounding area thousands of times. She indicated that people should feel fortunate that this area continues to be improved and modified to maintain its uniqueness and charm. She noted that there are many kinds of lot configurations with an assortment of house designs, and she found it interesting that each design seems to get along and support one another far better than the occupants of those homes. She stated that she is not sure of the definition of a historic or heritage area and wondered if it is when the house was built, because of who lived there, or because of a particular design. She stated that she is sure that everyone has a different opinion of this subject, and she thinks it is unfortunate that a committee of eight or twelve has become the Pleasanton Heritage Association and seems to think they can control Pleasanton with their opinion. Ms. Shapiro stated that she was not sure what the Oxsens' Sears Kit house has to do with Pleasanton's heritage; she was not aware that this type of home was part of the City and believes that the home was placed on a remnant lot left from Peters Avenue construction. She added that the lot has a peculiar alignment with the adjoining lot on St. Mary's Street, and she was not sure this is a good example of a Heritage selection. She stated that the Cunninghams are trying to be good neighbor; their design has been given much thought with regard to the area, the lot, and, more importantly, the livability of the dwelling. She added that there is nothing dear or historic about the Hall family compound anymore, and the same is true with their historical building on Main Street at Neal Street that has been replaced but still reflects its original design and relevance to the Downtown. She noted that the cottage does nothing for the area; it can hardly be seen from the street and usually has a motorcycle and two cars on the lawn in the front area. She stated that the Cunninghams wish to build their own home of hard structure that will not be modified; they are not building a rental. She added that if people did not want neighbors looking into their yards or have shade situations, they would have to live on huge lots, which does not make for a unique area like most downtown area. She stated that at her home, her neighbor behind her has a two-story home with three large picture windows along the back, and their other neighbor has a heritage tree that is so tall that it eliminates the sun from warming their pool water. She indicated that she hopes the Commission can make the findings to approve the proposal, as the Cunninghams want to be part of the Downtown neighborhood and want to be good neighbors. She added that they are trying to make an infill project that would add much to the area, another unique home which would blend nicely with the eclectic mix of the area. Bob Shapiro stated that he has been a Pleasanton resident since 1999, has been active in the City, has participated in many commissions, and has worked on community volunteer roles. He indicated that his passion is to sustain the value of the City, its amenities, and its beauty. He added that he has known the Cunninghams for over a EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, NOVEMBER 9, 2011 Page 10 of 17