11 ATTACHMENT 03 - Laserfiche WebLink

Chair Narum proposed a modification to the condition on the playground equipment that it be installed in conjunction with the Landscape Architect's determination of what play structure would be appropriate for the limited space. Commissioner Blank proposed the language "The type of play structure shall be subject to the review and approval of the Director of Community Development." Commissioners Pentin inquired if the stipulation included that the builder would have the vote of the HOA after the 1 lb lot is sold and that the tot lot will be paid for by the developer. Chair Narum said yes. Commissioners Blank and Pentin accepted the amendment. Commissioner O'Connor indicated that he is in agreement with Commissioner Blank's statement. Commissioner Pearce stated that her position on this property is well-known and that she is gratified that the City Council returned this to the Commission for further work. She indicated that she thinks this is a better project than it was when it was originally forwarded to the City Council, which has always been her hope. She added that she believes the applicant has satisfied the Council's direction in what has been done with the project and that, therefore, she will support the motion. Commissioner Pearce continued that she is disappointed that the house could not be saved; however, she believes that under the current City guidelines regarding preservation, these guidelines have been satisfied. She noted that an expert was asked to come in to determine whether or not this was a historical resource; the expert did that and determined that it was not. She reiterated that this underscores the importance of having historic preservation discussions, so that the City can determine what is important to the City and not be reliant on the State and Federal guidelines. She indicated that she is gratified that two additional trees have been saved but is disappointed that more could not be saved, although she understands the financial and other constraints of the project. She emphasized that she believes this is a very appropriate site for affordable-by-design homes that are within walking distance to the Downtown. Chair Narum agreed with Commissioner Pearce's comments and stated that she thinks this is not where the battle to saving houses is, that it is more to the south. She indicated that she wished more trees could be saved and that she supports the motion. EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, July 13, 2011 Page 9 of 10