PC 041311 - Laserfiche WebLink

Ms. Bourg stated that the Halls daughter inherited the home and cottage and was told that the City Code prevented her from renting out two dwellings on the same lot, the reason she was forced her to sell the property. She added that Jon Harvey purchased the property and subdivided it into two lots, and then Dave and Fran Cunningham purchased the lot containing both of the homes. She indicated that she attended the hearing regarding the lot split and was relieved that the Cunninghams were to live at the larger landmark home. She noted, however, that the Cunninghams ended up renting the home and the cottage and never lived on the property. She added that both properties have been rented for the last seven years and that the Cunninghams have attempted to sell the property twice. Ms. Bourg stated that in 2009, she was notified of the current proposal and concerns. She indicated that subsequent changes were made to call for a 25-foot high, two-story, 1,800-square-foot home requiring six variances, which she noted staff continues to oppose. She echoed comments regarding the concerns brought forward by her husband. She stated that the house would sit on the dripline of their large oak tree, and she fears that the Cunninghams could request that the lot be split in the future. Ms. Bourg stated that the loss of the cottage would be a loss of City history, and she implored the Cunninghams to save it and restore the old family home to live in. She indicated that she contacted at least 12 families who oppose the project and would be most affected by it. She then read into the record a letter from Debbie Ayres, a neighbor who could not be present at the meeting: of the home infringes upon the privacy of its neighbors. I recently bought an adjacent home on Second Street not knowing that already the home on another side of my property has expansion plans approved. These things will not only affect my privacy, but may impact my property value by being squished in the middle. block. If the Cunningham high rise is built, my yard will be surrounded by five different neighbors instead of four. Although I am currently surrounded by four neighbors, none look directly into my backyard and bedroom window. The Cunningham plan posit privacy. The two story building also blocks my view of the skyline (heritage trees and sky) that came with my recent purchase as a reminder of where I live. years ago, because of the five antique stores on Main Street. I loved the old houses surrounding downtown that added to its charm. ts historic homes and PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MINUTES, April 13, 2011 Page 7 of 19