CCMIN040610 - Laserfiche WebLink

Councilmember Cook Kallio said that one of the things asked of the Council at its last meeting was to support workers in their quest to return to work. She said that a lockout, particularly when no strike was eminent, is profound and that workers would like to return to the negotiating table. Councilmember Sullivan said one can judge a community by the way it treats its least powerful members. He said this sort of issue does not often arise in Pleasanton and it is an opportunity for the Council to do the right thing. He said he has met with workers and the union, has walked their picket line, and can say that all they wish to do is return to work and be able to negotiate in good faith. He said it warms his heart to see so many come out and speak in support of this resolution, particularly those not directly affected by the lockout. Vice -Mayor Thorne voiced disappointment that the other side was not represented in public comments or in the staff report. Mayor Hosterman said she met with the Club's general manager and others, making it clear that the item would be heard at tonight's meeting and inviting them to attend and share their position. Councilmember Cook Kallio said she made three calls to the General Manager, none of which have been returned. She makes no judgment on what the General Manager would say at the negotiating table but reiterated that the problem cannot be resolved if no one is willing to talk about it. Vice -Mayor Thorne said he did not disagree with the need to resume negotiations but that asking management to end the lockout seems to be taking sides. He said a lockout is a management strategy like a strike is a labor strategy and questioned if the Council would take the same sort of action if this were a worker initiated strike. He is not comfortable, as a public entity, with insisting that the Club end the lockout or with the comments stating that, the matter has cast Pleasanton in a poor light, which he does not necessarily believe to be true. He sincerely desires for both parties to resume negotiating in good faith and that, if the two statements identified were to be removed, he could support the resolution. Mayor Hosterman said the proposed language is a fair assessment of the current situation and that it appropriately and strongly encourages management to invite the workers back to the table and back to work. She requested suggestions from the Council or staff on how to bifurcate the issue so that Vice -Mayor Thorne may vote in support of the general action but not necessarily the language of the resolution. Councilmember Sullivan said he could support eliminating the comments regarding how this reflects on Pleasanton because while he believed it to be true, it may not be that important. He said it is crucial to leave the wording requesting an end to the lockout because good faith negotiations cannot occur in such an imbalanced situation. He is happy to take sides in the matter and in fact has, but he does not believe that is what this resolution accomplishes. Vice -Mayor Thorne said he might side with the laborers, both as an individual and a member of CCOP, but that he is not comfortable doing so as a public entity by demanding that management take a certain action. City Council Minutes Page 7 of 22 April 6, 2010