PC 111809 - Laserfiche WebLink

Commissioner Pentin arrived at this point of the meeting. Dr. Howard Long, neighbor, indicated that he is generally happy to see the restaurant thrive but cited public nuisances, including smoking, which he believes the City can help mitigate. He stated that he believes the problem is the bass level from the music and the direction the music faces. To check the public nuisances, he suggested that the chains be removed, a sign installed that identifies the smoking area, and bricks and protection from the weather be installed in the area to allow Redcoats to improve its business by helping to concentrate smoking. Vicki Salinas, friend of the applicant, stated that she has seen Mari Kennard through two restaurant openings and is a supporter of the restaurant. She indicated that she believes no one can address smokers because it is difficult to control what smokers do unless they are physically hand-held. She acknowledged the Finches’ concerns but noted that Ms. Kennard keeps her building’s doors closed as opposed to other adjacent businesses that do otherwise. She noted that Ms. Kennard personally cleans up the area and expressed her support for allowing music two more nights a week. She felt the good neighbor policy works well for a residential neighborhood and asked property owners to be more tolerant, given that they live in the Downtown area next to three thriving restaurants. She stated that wanted to see all Downtown businesses thrive and urged the Commission to approve the application. Deborah Kostal stated that a business that follows all guidelines should have the ability to operate within those guidelines, and provide jobs for people, money for the City, and a place for many to congregate. She indicated that she felt it was atrocious for one person who knowingly chose to move next door to a pub to have the potential to cripple the business because of music being played. She provided examples that those moving next to an airport or an elementary school should realize there would be some noise in the neighborhood. She pointed out that it would not make any sense for a business to even consider opening in Pleasanton if this is how businesses would be treated. Joel Cacia stated that he grew up on the north side of town and moved to Downtown Pleasanton in 1991 because of its liveliness with events such as concerts in the park, Wednesday night street parties, and live music in area restaurants, which add value to the quality of life in the area. He added that events such as these give residents motivation to get out of the house and away from the television and to socialize. He noted that too often, the complaints of a few are given more consideration than the silent approval of many. He expressed his support for Redcoats to provide music on Wednesday and Thursday nights. Michael O’Callaghan stated that he supported approval of the project. He indicated that he has known Ms. Kennard for years and agrees that anyone who moves into the Downtown should expect activity. He noted that Ms. Kennard agreed with the mitigation of a few things and that Mr. Finch supported the project with the exception of the problems with the smoking and cigarette butts. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, November 18, 2009 Page 7 of 25